Posts

Why Your Company's Training Budget is Being Wasted (And How I Finally Fixed Mine)

Three months ago, I watched my HR director write a $47,000 cheque for a leadership development program that had about as much impact as a chocolate teapot. The facilitator showed up with PowerPoint slides from 2019, ran the same "trust fall" exercise my grandfather probably did in the 1970s, and left behind a stack of workbooks that are now collecting dust in our storage room.

That was my wake-up call. After fifteen years running training programs across Melbourne and Brisbane, I finally admitted what I'd been avoiding: most corporate training is an expensive exercise in box-ticking that changes absolutely nothing.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Training ROI

Here's what nobody wants to tell you at those industry conferences: 84% of training programs fail to deliver measurable business outcomes within six months. I made that statistic up, but it feels about right based on what I've seen. The real numbers are probably worse.

Last year alone, Australian businesses spent over $8 billion on professional development. That's enough money to buy every employee in the country a decent coffee machine. At least then we'd all be more alert during meetings.

The problem isn't that training doesn't work. It's that we're doing it completely wrong.

Why Most Training Programs Are Glorified Entertainment

Walk into any corporate training session and you'll see the same pattern. Twenty people sitting in uncomfortable chairs, half-heartedly participating in role-plays about "difficult conversations" while secretly checking their phones under the table. The trainer – usually someone who's never managed a team in their life – delivers generic advice that sounds profound but means nothing.

I've been guilty of this myself. Early in my career, I ran communication training sessions that were basically expensive therapy sessions. People would nod enthusiastically, fill out their feedback forms with glowing reviews, then return to work and immediately revert to their old habits.

The issue is that most training treats symptoms, not causes. You can teach someone the "STAR method" for giving feedback until you're blue in the face, but if their manager doesn't model good communication, if the company culture rewards people who stay quiet, if there's no accountability for applying new skills – well, you might as well have spent that money on a team lunch.

At least with lunch, people actually show up willingly.

The Three Fatal Flaws I Keep Seeing

Flaw #1: One-Size-Fits-All Thinking

Your accounts receivable clerk doesn't need the same leadership training as your operations manager. Sounds obvious, right? Yet I constantly see companies cramming everyone from graduate trainees to senior executives into identical programs.

It's like teaching everyone to drive using the same car, regardless of whether they're planning to deliver pizzas or compete in Formula One.

Flaw #2: Training Without Context

Here's a radical idea: maybe we should connect training to actual business problems. I once worked with a manufacturing company that spent $30,000 on "innovation workshops" while their main issue was basic quality control. They needed process improvement training, not blue-sky brainstorming sessions about the future of widgets.

Flaw #3: No Follow-Up

This is the big one. Training without reinforcement is like going to the gym once and expecting to look like Chris Hemsworth. Most programs end with a certificate ceremony and a LinkedIn post about "professional development." Six weeks later, it's as if the training never happened.

What Actually Works (From Someone Who's Learned the Hard Way)

After years of watching training budgets disappear into the ether, I finally figured out what separates effective programs from expensive time-wasters.

First, start with a proper needs analysis. Not a survey asking "What training would you like?" – that's how you end up with requests for "Excel for Beginners" from people who've been using spreadsheets for a decade. Talk to managers about specific performance gaps. Look at your customer complaints. Analyse your turnover data.

When Telstra revamped their customer service training a few years back, they didn't start with generic "customer service excellence" modules. They listened to actual customer calls, identified specific problem patterns, and built training around real scenarios their staff encountered daily. Revolutionary stuff.

Second, make training immediately applicable. The best professional development programs I've seen give people tools they can use that same afternoon. No theory for theory's sake. No abstract concepts that might be useful "one day."

Third, build in accountability. This means follow-up sessions, peer coaching, manager check-ins, and yes, measuring actual behaviour change. It's harder work than delivering a one-off workshop, but it's the difference between training that sticks and training that evaporates.

The Psychology of Adult Learning (That Trainers Seem to Forget)

Adults learn differently than university students, but you wouldn't know it from most corporate training programs. We're dealing with people who have mortgages, kids' soccer games, and fifteen years of established work habits. They don't want to sit through lectures about theoretical frameworks.

They want practical solutions to real problems they're facing right now.

I learned this lesson the hard way during a disastrous training session in 2019. I'd prepared this elaborate presentation about emotional intelligence theory, complete with neuroscience research and fancy diagrams. Fifteen minutes in, I could see I'd lost the room. These were experienced managers dealing with actual team conflicts, and I was talking about the amygdala.

The session turned around when someone asked, "What do I do when my team member keeps interrupting me in meetings?" Finally, a real problem we could solve together.

The Technology Trap

Let's talk about e-learning for a minute. Every software vendor will tell you their platform is the future of corporate training. Microlearning! Gamification! AI-powered personalisation!

Here's the thing: most online training programs have completion rates lower than my nephew's attention span during school assembly. People click through modules to get their certificates, learning about as much as they would from reading the terms and conditions on iTunes.

That said, technology has its place. Coles uses mobile learning brilliantly for their retail training – short, specific modules that staff can access during quiet periods. The key is making it relevant and convenient, not just cheaper than face-to-face delivery.

Measuring What Matters

This might be controversial, but I think the entire training industry has been measuring the wrong things for decades. We obsess over satisfaction scores ("Did you enjoy the session?") and knowledge tests ("Can you list the five steps of active listening?") while ignoring the only metric that actually matters: did performance improve?

I've seen training programs with 95% satisfaction rates that delivered zero business impact. People enjoyed the day out of the office, the catered lunch, and the motivational speakers. But did they actually change how they work? Did customer complaints decrease? Did team productivity improve? Did staff turnover drop?

Usually, nobody bothers to check.

The Manager Problem

Here's something that keeps me awake at night: we spend thousands training individual contributors while their managers remain completely unprepared to support skill development. It's like sending someone to driving lessons then handing them keys to a car with no brakes.

Managers make or break training effectiveness. If they don't understand what their people learned, can't recognise when new skills are being applied, and aren't equipped to provide ongoing coaching – well, that's money down the drain.

The best companies I work with now train managers first. Not after. Not at the same time. First.

What I'd Do With Your Training Budget Tomorrow

If you handed me your training budget tomorrow, here's exactly what I'd do:

Start by talking to your best performers. What skills separate them from average performers? How did they develop those skills? What support did they need along the way?

Then look at your biggest performance challenges. Not what people think they need, but what your business actually needs. Are deals getting stuck in the pipeline? Are customer complaints increasing? Is turnover high in specific roles?

Build training around solving those specific problems. Use real scenarios from your workplace. Involve your best performers as mentors and coaches. Make it immediately applicable.

And for the love of all that's holy, follow up. Training without reinforcement is like planting seeds then never watering them.

The Real Cost of Bad Training

The opportunity cost of ineffective training goes beyond the direct expense. There's the time people spend away from productive work. The cynicism that builds when staff sit through program after program without seeing meaningful change. The good employees who leave because they're not developing professionally.

I once worked with a law firm that had such a reputation for boring, irrelevant training that partners would literally reschedule client meetings to avoid attending mandatory sessions. That's not just wasted money – that's active damage to your culture.

A Final Thought

Look, I'm not anti-training. I make my living delivering professional development programs, and I've seen firsthand how the right training at the right time can transform careers and businesses.

But I am absolutely against the lazy, box-ticking approach that treats training as an HR compliance exercise rather than a strategic business investment.

Your people want to grow. They want to get better at what they do. They want training that respects their intelligence and helps them solve real problems.

Give them that, and your training budget will start looking like the best money you've ever spent.

Otherwise, you might as well buy everyone coffee machines.

Our Favourite Training Resources: Communication Skills Development | Skills Training for Career Growth | Professional Development Courses